This was my first supper club and it was an interesting experience. I loved the vintage look of the bar and asked a staff member if you could eat at the bar. I was told yes. So, took a seat at the bar and was greeted by the bartender right away and given a decent Manhattan. I then sat for a good 50 mintues before someone took my order. Normally this would ruin a place, but I have to say, once the food arrived it was amazing. The cheese curds, the white fish, the shrimp, and even the salads were great. I guess next time I'll sit in the main dining hall.
Great classic supper club fare but a little light on the normal accoutrements in the relish tray area. Nice touch with the crackers and cheese spread though. The dinner service was prompt and helpful.
Please try the all you can eat prime rib. I had four slices, it's amazing.
Great customer service! Huge salad, and the prime rib all you can eat at a decent price was delicious! Can't go wrong with The Mill Supper Club!
The place was good and seemed to have a mix of locals and visitors, which is always a good sign.
Unfortunately we had a miss with a brandy old fashioned sweet drink order. It was very lacking in the sweet area, almost seltzery and when I brought back to the bar, they said they had no simple syrup to add (!?) and I had them add more white soda instead. It was better but not right, I should have had them remake it in hindsight. I don't know what happened there. Our table just had waters the rest of the night.
The prime rib was the best my husband ever had, huge portion. Baked chicken was very moist. Only disappointment were the mashed potatoes, which were tasty, but only lukewarm. They did replace my husband's, which were then hot, but failed to replace.mine. Cranberries great, stuffing tasteless. We would go back without a doubt.
Mill Supper Club is a US Bar based in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin. Mill Supper Club is located at 4128 WI-42, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, USA.
Please contact with Mill Supper Club using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Mill Supper Club opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.
Find Bar in Sturgeon Bay